Lou Paget logo

BDSM Gags Tested and Ranked

Top Picks for BDSM Gags

When it comes to exploring BDSM, finding the right gag can intensify the experience for those looking to dive into role-play or power exchange dynamics.

I’ve combed through countless options and selected some of the best BDSM gags on the market, designed for comfort, safety, and of course, silence. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned enthusiast, my curated list aims to cater to all levels of experience and preference.

best bdsm gags

Table of Contents

#1 Bondage Boutique Dog Bone Gag

I’ve recently checked out the Dog Bone Gag and it’s struck a chord with us for its impressive comfort and adaptability. The fake leather strap didn’t chafe, which is a huge plus because nobody wants to be distracted by discomfort when they’re in the moment.

Pros

  • Adjustable fit for various head sizes
  • The silicone bar is bite-friendly and doesn’t hurt your teeth
  • Faux leather feels soft against the skin

Cons

  • The buckle could be more robust
  • Loose strap end can be annoying unless tucked away
  • Packaging could be more discreet for privacy

Thoughtful design has gone into making the silicone dog bone bar. At 5 inches long, it sits comfortably in the mouth, reducing the jaw fatigue that other gags can cause over time. The simplicity of cleaning the gag after use makes it all the more appealing—it just takes a quick wash, and it’s ready for another go.

I’ve noticed a minor hiccup with the strap ending sticking out, which can seem a bit unruly. While it’s not a dealbreaker, a midway loop to secure the end might upgrade the overall aesthetic, ensuring that everything looks sleek and in place.

Considering the combination of comfort, adjustability, and practicality, the Dog Bone Gag has certainly earned its place in my collection of toys. Its few faults don’t overshadow the quality experience it provides, making it a worthy addition, especially for those new to gags or looking for a more comfortable alternative to ball gags.

#2 O-Ring Gag

My recent foray into experimenting with the O-Ring Open Mouth Gag added a thrilling twist. The silicone material is top-notch, providing a soft but firm hold without any irritation or discomfort; it’s easy to forget you’re even wearing it.

o-ring gag

Pros

  • Made of body-safe silicone, it’s gentle on the mouth
  • The adjustable leather strap ensures a snug fit for most
  • Discreet packaging keeps your adventure under wraps

Cons

  • Some may find the ring’s size limiting for certain activities
  • The absence of a padlock in the package can be disappointing
  • The synthetic strap may not meet the expectations of leather purists

Adjustability is key to comfort, and the leather strap didn’t disappoint. It adapted well to various head sizes among us, which meant everyone had the chance to join in without any hassle.

The discretion of the packaging was appreciated. It allowed me to keep our private explorations just that—private.

On the flip side, while the gag’s ring size was just right for some, others in my group hoped for a bit more versatility. The missing padlock was a minor hiccup—nothing a quick trip to the hardware store couldn’t fix, but it’s a detail worth noting.

Lastly, while the strap touts are leather, those with a keen eye for materials might catch on to its synthetic nature. However, it did the job for me in terms of both look and functionality.

#3 Red-Ball Gag

I’ve just got my hands on the Red-Ball Gag and can’t help but notice how the quality strikes a fine balance between firmness and comfort. The silicone ball is sturdy enough to withstand a serious session, yet gentle enough so that it doesn’t feel like a dentist’s punishment.

As I buckled it on, the leather strap felt soft against the skin and the additional lock feature ensured that it stayed precisely where it was meant to. It was easy to adjust, fitting snugly but not uncomfortably so.

red ball gag

Pros

  • Made from silicone, you can bite down hard without any dental worries.
  • Superior leather strap equipped with a lock for extra security and durability.
  • Its adjustable strap ensures a comfortable fit for a variety of head sizes.

Cons

  • Potential size issues for very small necks due to limited holes on the strap.
  • Some may receive a different color than expected, which can be disappointing.
  • The leather strap, while of decent quality, may not rise to everyone’s expectations.

When considering practicality, the ball gag accommodated various jaw sizes with ease. I didn’t feel too overwhelmed, which is a common concern with less thoughtfully designed gags. You can chomp away without hesitation—a quite liberating sensation, honestly. And I have to mention the discreet shipping; knowing your privacy is protected adds an extra level of comfort to the purchase.

Yet, nothing is perfect. A companion with a particularly petite neck mentioned the fit wasn’t as tight as they’d like, leaving me wishing for a few extra buckle holes. I’ve also heard some quibbles about the color nuances, and I get why it’s important—visuals do matter in setting the mood. As for the leather strap, while it serves its purpose well, others might be seeking an even higher-end material.

Overall, my experience with the Red-Ball Gag was more than satisfactory. It enhances playtime without breaking the bank or compromising on safety and comfort. Whether you’re just dabbling in BDSM or you’re a seasoned enthusiast, this gag might just be what you need to muffle those moans artfully.

#4 Dark Amour Breathable Ball Gag

I recently got my hands on the Dark Amour Breathable Gag and what an experience it was! Diving straight into the fun, the freshness of the leather scent and the cool, smooth steel were immediate signs of both quality and potential indulgence.

breathable ball gag

Pros

  • Unites bondage and anal play neatly
  • Offers noteworthy adjustability for comfort
  • Crafted from quality materials for longevity

Cons

  • Sizing may not fit everyone perfectly
  • Might be intimidating for BDSM novices
  • Neck strap Velcro may lack long-term durability

I must say, the flexibility and adjustable straps were pretty good. It wasn’t just about getting tied up; it was about getting tied up with a perfect fit. O could easily switch things up and adapt the restraints without losing a moment of excitement.

Combining pleasure with restriction isn’t always easy, but this set made it seem effortless. Whether I played gently or pushed limits, the sturdy leather held strong, and that anal hook? It’s a game-changer; delivering pressure exactly where you want it—intense doesn’t even begin to cover it.

For couples ready to explore deeper realms of their BDSM play, the Dark Amour Gag is a worthy candidate.

#5 CozyFit

When I gave the CozyFit Breathable Gag a whirl, the most striking benefit was the gag’s breathable design. With precisely drilled holes, breathing was as comfortable as can be, even during the most intense moments of play. Its medical-grade silicone material didn’t have even a hint of any off-putting smell, and it felt soft against the skin—no chafing or discomfort at any point of the night.

cozyfit

Pros

  • Perfectly sized holes for easy breathing
  • Soft, medical-grade silicone for comfort
  • Easily adjustable for a snug fit

Cons

  • Might be too big for smaller mouths
  • Can cause drooling due to holes
  • Limited size expansion for larger heads

The adjustable strap deserves a shoutout too. I found it pretty straightforward to find the perfect fit—neither too tight nor too loose. The CozyFit stayed in place flawlessly, proving it can keep up with a range of activities without constant readjustment.

However, it’s not all perfect. If you or your partner have a smaller mouth, you may want to think twice. The ball’s size could be slightly overwhelming, and despite the convenience of the holes, they do create a bit of a drooling situation. Not necessarily a deal-breaker, but something to consider. Plus, those with larger heads might find the strap’s maximum extension a tad restrictive.

All in all, I see why the CozyFit Breathable Gag is a top pick. It strikes an appealing balance between silence and comfort, enhancing our play without a single worry about safety or ease of breathing. A solid addition to my collection.

Buying Guide

When I’m on the hunt for the best BDSM gags, I have to consider several key factors. To make this process a bit simpler, let’s break it down into categories.

Safety Features

First and foremost is safety. I want to ensure that the gag can be removed quickly in case of an emergency. Quick-release buckles or safety catches are a must.

  • Materials:Non-toxic, body-safe materials should be your go-to choice.
  • Adjustability:Straps should be adjustable to fit comfortably and securely.

Comfort

Long sessions mean comfort is crucial.

  • Padding:Check for cushioning around the areas that will be under strain.
  • Fit:Gags should not cause jaw ache; appropriate sizing is essential.

Types of Gags

Different gags offer unique experiences. Here’s a brief rundown:

Type

Ideal for

Ball Gag

Classic, muffle sounds

Bit Gag

Comfort, easy to bite on

O-Ring Gag

Oral access, drool-inducing

Panel Gag

Full mouth cover, muffles more sound

Filler Gag

Keeps mouth packed and quiet

Durability

I’ll want something that lasts, so quality construction and sturdy materials are key.

  • Stitching:Look for reinforced stitching.
  • Hardware:Metal hardware tends to be more durable than plastic.

Aesthetics

Lastly, the appearance adds to the experience.

  • Style:Choose something that resonates with your aesthetic preferences.
  • Color:Usually, black is standard, but other colors can match different moods or scenes.

Remember, the best gag for me is one that aligns with my comfort, safety, and the kind of scene I want to create. Happy shopping!